Sony / Minolta AF System

Lens Reviews
Lens Comparisons
DSLRs
SLRs

Minolta SR System

Lenses
SR-System SLRs
A900: Minolta AF 1.4/85mm, 2/100mm, Zeiss ZA 1.4/85mm

 

Portraetteles_MinAF85mm_Hamid

The Minolta AF 1.4/85mm has rather pronounced spherical aberrations. Wide open, the lens displayes lots of detail, but the overall microcontrast is quite low.Stopped down to f2.8 the contrast increases to normal values, and the focus slightly shifts backwards - this is a consequence of the undercorrected spherical aberrations.

For portraiture, these characteristics can be quite useful. Skin details have a pleasant appearance - they are visible, but they don't distract from the overall image.

Portraetteles_ZeissZA85mm_Hamid The Zeiss Planar T* ZA 1.4/85mm is slightly harsher wide open, and stopped down we observe a slight front-focus.
Portraetteles_MinAF100mm_Hamid The Minolta AF 2/100mm has well corrected spherical aberrations and a characteristics similar to the Zeiss 1.8/135mm. Detail resolution and contrast are very good at f2, and excellent from f2.8 onwards.

The two following series are details from St. Peter in Rome (Italy).

We can see that the remaining spherical aberrations of the Minolta AF 1.4/85mm are stronger than those of the Zeiss. Nevertheless the Minolta images look more pleasant to me: Used wide open, the lens causes highlights to "glow" from inside; the Zeiss images at f1.4 look somehow dead. Stopped town to f2, the Minolta AF 1.4/85mm is at least as good as the Zeiss, and the Minolta AF 2/100mm. At f4.5 all three lenses are simply outstanding.

Portraetteles_MinAF85mm_VatikanCupola

Images of the Minolta AF 1.4/85mm can have a very pleasant, shiny look ("The Glow") if the lens is used wide open.

Stopped down to f4.5 the lens becomes outstanding, both regarding detail resolution and microcontrast.

Portraetteles_ZeissZA85mm_VatikanCupola

The Zeiss has much less spherical aberrations, and much less Koma as well. Nevertheless, at f1.4 the Zeiss doesn't look as pleasant as the Minolta.

At f 4.5 the Zeiss images are as crisp and detailed as the Minolta images.

Portraetteles_MinAF100mm_VatikanCupola
Portraetteles_MinAF85mm_VatikanFenster
Portraetteles_ZeissZA85mm_VatikanFenster
Portraetteles_MinAF100mm_VatikanFenster

BOKEH: It is quite a surprise to see that the Zeiss 1.4/85mm bokeh wide open is clearly better than the Minolta 1.4/85mm bokeh. In the past, Zeiss lenses often were criticized beacuse of their harsh background blur, but obviously they know now how to do it better.

Stopped down to f2.8 and further, the bokeh of the two lenses becomes very similar.

Portraetteles_Bokeh_ZA85_vs_MAF85

 

COMA: The Zeiss 1.4/85mm is clearly better than the Minolta 1.4/85mm - especially wide open and, to a lesser extent also at f2.
From f2.8 on the differences are neglectible.

Koma